| Councils and
Boards often vote on unnecessary and confusing motions. They may have
done so for years and continue to do it, out of force of habit, even
if it makes no sense. There appears to be a fear of letting go and a
concern that change will place the Council or Board in procedural jeopardy.
One example of such unnecessary procedure is the motion to receive a
report or a letter that is presented for information only.
The problem with
voting on a motion to receive a report is that it is confusing, because
it validates action that already took place, i.e.: A report is received
by virtue of the fact that it was scheduled on the agenda and was presented.
What is the purpose of voting to receive it after the fact? Yes, there
may be no consequence if the motion to receive is adopted. But what
if it is defeated? Would this mean that the report was not received?
Can the Council or Board change history? Plus, what is the meaning of
speaking or voting against the motion to receive?
If you are tempted
to let go of this procedure but need reassurance that it’s OK
to do so, here is a quote from Robert’s Rules of Order Newly Revised
(10th edition, page 491): “In fact, this motion (to receive, EM)
is meaningless since the report has already been received”.
Some Councils and
Boards believe that it is necessary to formally acknowledge that a report
was on the agenda. Others believe that a motion is needed on every proceeding
or else it can be deemed to be invalid. Even if this concern was legitimate,
there is a simpler way of addressing it:
Instead of moving
that every report be received, one motion can be made at the start of
the meeting that all agenda items, including reports and correspondence,
be received, i.e.: scheduled on the agenda. Alternatively, using plain
language, a motion to approve the agenda can be approved at the start
of the meeting. The effect of this motion is to agree – before
the fact – that all reports that are listed on the agenda will
be presented and – if needed – considered. This approach
will be clear and meaningful. |
